U.S. Housing Market A Deepening Divide

The U.S. housing market shows a stark divide between homeowners and prospective buyers, highlighting an affordability gap. Homeowners benefit from current property values, while prospective buyers struggle with high prices. Despite an expected Federal Reserve rate cut next week, this disparity persists. Lower rates may not significantly bridge the affordability gap. The market remains segmented, with challenges for prospective buyers continuing.

Impact of Potential Rate Cut

The Federal Reserve’s expected reduction in short-term interest rates will likely make home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) less expensive for homeowners. This will enable them to access their home equity more affordably. Homeowners who purchased properties in late 2023 or early 2024, during a period of elevated mortgage rates, are particularly benefiting from the recent decline in borrowing costs. According to the Mortgage Bankers Association, mortgage refinancing applications surged more than double compared to the same week last year, as of September 6.

The U.S. housing market lower short-term rates HELOCs cheaper, benefiting recent homeowners, according to wsj subscription deals.

Challenges for Prospective Buyers

While mortgage rates have decreased from last year’s peaks, they still don’t counterbalance other market challenges for prospective buyers. Home prices remain near record highs, many areas face constrained housing inventory, and rising costs for insurance and property taxes inflate overall expenses. Affordability remains a significant issue, said Christine Cooper, chief U.S. economist at CoStar Group. Prices are still high.

Growing Wealth Gap

The U.S. housing market divide underscores the widening wealth gap between homeowners and renters. Since 2019, home prices have surged over 50%, significantly boosting homeowners’ wealth. As of July, homeowners with mortgages had accumulated $17.5 trillion in equity, according to Intercontinental Exchange.

Mortgage Rate Trends

The mortgage outlook has improved, with the 30-year fixed mortgage rate falling to 6.2% this month from a 23-year high of 7.79% last fall, according to Freddie Mac. This decrease is partly attributed to anticipated Federal Reserve rate cuts by at least 0.25 percentage points at their September 17-18 meeting, with further reductions expected.

Consumer Inflation Expectations Stabilize Amid Rising Debt

Recent data shows that consumer inflation expectations have remained stable for both short- and long-term periods. According to a survey…

Refinancing Success Stories

David Cerutti from Tenafly, N.J., purchased a home in November with an 8.124% mortgage rate. He recently refinanced to a 6.125% rate, significantly reducing his monthly payments. Cerutti plans to use the savings to pay down his mortgage principal more quickly. It was a substantial decrease in my monthly payment,” Cerutti said. “I feel fantastic about the new rate and the opportunity to save money.

Limited Relief for Non-Homeowners

For non-homeowners, mortgage rates would need to fall below 5.25% for the cost of a median-priced home to become cheaper than renting, according to Nick Villa, an economist at Moody’s. “If you’ve been a homeowner since the pandemic, you’re in a great position,” Villa said. “If you weren’t able to buy then and started looking in 2023 or 2024, you’re facing a problem.”

Increasing HELOC Demand

Homeowners increasingly tap into their home equity. About 90% of homeowners with mortgages can borrow against their equity while keeping a 20% cushion. Total HELOC balances reached $380 billion in the second quarter, up nearly 12% from last year. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York reported this increase. Many borrowers use HELOCs for debt consolidation, as credit card balances rose to $1.14 trillion in the second quarter.

Prospective Buyers’ Struggles

Lenders anticipate continued HELOC demand if the Fed lowers short-term rates. Barry Cohen of Woodmere, N.Y., hopes for reduced payments. However, non-homeowners may not benefit much, as economists suggest current mortgage rates already reflect expectations for lower rates.

Since early 2022, the Fed’s rate hikes aimed to cool the economy and curb inflation, pricing many out of the market. Travis Eaton and his girlfriend started house hunting in Minneapolis in December and made around 10 offers. They either faced being outbid or found homes in poor condition within their $200,000 to $300,000 budget. “I secured a good job, maintained a strong credit score, and saved money—I did everything right,” Eaton said.

Despite some improvement in home-buying affordability this summer, many buyers remain hesitant to re-enter the market. Some have signed new leases and plan to return next year, while others feel deterred by potential job market slowdowns or frustrated by persistently high home prices.

Enroll today for a 77% discount on a 2-year digital subscription to Financial Times and The New York Times. Enjoy unlimited access to updates, crosswords, The Economist Epaper, and expert analyses.